Recently I had the experience of being labelled by another person because I did not and do not share the same viewpoint as them. I was labelled both homophobic and transphobic. I took what they said and have sat with it and sort counsel from my spiritual advisors throughout the Lenten season.
I realised after seeking this counsel and sitting with it, that I am not what this person chose to label me as. Why can I say that for sure, because to be truly phobic, you actually have to a hate within yourself of the other thing. I don’t hate either the homosexual or the trans community. I have serious concerns as to how they are treated, I have even more serious concerns as to how the trans community are treated. In my own ways, I have worked privately through theology to get the serious bioethical concerns that I have, raised but like many theologians, medicine isn’t listening and neither is psychology.
My concerns though are valid. The homosexual community has not been treated with respect. That is a given and a point that any reasonable person will agree with. Many governments, including the one in the country that I live in, have moved to fix and are still moving to fix issues. There is progress, there is growth and time will continue to change and bring about more understanding.
The trans community in particular are very vulnerable, simply because neither medicine or psychology truly understand the whys, as to why trans people feel the way they do. Much more research and much more support must be given to these folk. My concern though lies with the why side. My question remains as to how many of these folk are being given a pat answers, that long term may not be the right one.
The old adage, “if in doubt, don’t” comes to mind. If a person is not sure what gender they are, they should be given time to sort through feelings and emotions. Given support to explore their life and see if trauma is involved or abuse is involved or other factors. Above all else, they should not be rushed onto a cocktail of body and mind altering medications that lead to changes that cannot be reversed. If this is the correct path for them, then taking time should not be an issue. Instead in many cases, it only takes a matter of months for an already confused person to be put on hormones that bring lasting change. Science has no right to use these folk as lab rats and in essence that is what science is doing.
What about the long term costs? For example, a male to female trans women, has a far higher risk of breast cancer. To maintain the body as female, hormones will need to adjusted and in some cases raised as they age. Whereas a naturally born women goes through menopause and those hormones drop. What feeds most breast cancers….female hormones. So, where does that leave trans women? I will tell you, stuck between two choices, death or stopping hormones. Simply because the science of breast cancer is based on naturally born women and the treatments are based on naturally born women.
In our modern society, this is totally unacceptable! No one group should be hung out to dry like that. You see, when my now former friend had someone close to her decide to transition, I got off my ass and read everything that I could get my hands on, so that I could understand. What scares me even more is the move to block natural development in children who are gender unsure. Again, the whys here are way too thin on the ground.
As a five year old, my gender was the least of my concerns and certainly did not even remotely wander into my thinking patterns. What is causing children so young to be asking questions like that? Children should be enjoying being children, not being so confused and hurt that they need to explore issues like this so young. These things show society failing people on a grand scale. Again, the whys are not being looked at, at the level they should be.
But hold on Veiled, you are a theologian, does that come in somewhere….yes it does and this is where my fears become ones that can keep a person up at night. Judge not is just one piece of counsel that comes from the scripture. And that is why I mostly keep my mouth shut on this issue and do my work quietly behind the scenes. We live in a world of noise and to be heard, there is this need for groups to try and out yell each other. We have several movements who are yelling right now, we have feminists, racial issues, gender, sexuality etc and they all are trying to not only out yell each other, they are also putting down others to raise their issues higher. Learn from history and the mistakes of those areas that you want to change. You were put down, what makes you think that by putting down others, you will make more progress. All you are doing is the same things as those who put you down. The definition of insanity comes to mind here, and that is “you expect to get different results by doing the same things, the same way”. Sorry folks but it simply won’t happen.
Yelling won’t work long term. What happens though is that the louder you yell, the closer to noise it becomes and its message gets lost in the noise. Folks can only take noise for so long before they shut their ears. There is a lot of ear shutting happening because folks are not learning to talk without yelling. What works better is local movements who find understanding without yelling. Platforms like social media are great for raising issues but the lines become fine when folks frame things with hashtags to push issues. After the 50th hashtag, even the most patient of folks are going to glaze over and only hear noise.
For me there is a more fundamental concern that no piece of literature has addressed.
We are created and the scripture on this point is as blunt as heck….it says male and female. Yes, there can be hiccups due to genetics and accidents that might inhibit the body but what about the soul. That bit of you that comes from God. For it to match, the soul has to be gendered and that gender needs to match the body that it is placed in. Otherwise God in whatever form that person takes the Divine to be, would be nothing more than a lesser Being who makes major mistakes. All knowing, all powerful and everywhere God is not going to stuff up that royally. And that is where I get super uncomfortable. If the soul is gendered and that soul matches that body, the confusion felt by a person is only going to be so much worse when you add gender issues to it. You are literally trying to change something that has been created perfectly and loved to bits by God, into something else.
And no, I am not saying that issues cannot happen but on a longer and more eternal scale, I am saying what right does anyone have to play God. And that is why, the whys are important.
It is possible that if you got to the why, a percentage of folks, simply may not feel the way they do. Body dysmorphia can come from mental health issues, genetic issues, family history, abuse and trauma and other issues. A person that gets the why, may come in time to accept the vessel they are in and accept and love themselves because someone gave them the grace of time to work within to do so.
There will be folks who this will not work for and they will need even greater support to find the whys. There are still folks who will be born, for whatever reason with imbalances that might require hormones and surgery to place them in the body they should be in. There are still children born, who are born with parts from both genders. In times past, gender was assigned. These days, they wait and see which gender is more dominant once puberty arrives or the body itself via hormone testing etc can give those hints. There is more than one pathway. The current pathway though is not sustainable. Its a spiritual and ethical minefield that does not need pat solutions. Here take these pills, revisit puberty and see you in 8 weeks, is not a solution if in 20 years those same pills are going to kill you. Here take these pills is not a solution when you pass from this life and possibly find out that what you did was not in harmony with the Divine Being that created you and the cost is an eternal one.
The solution is to slow the heck down. Stop trying to bandaide wounds that need to be fully cleaned out and the whys found. And even more so, maybe its time folks accepted that someone does not need to fully agree with you to care. They are not against you if they have another viewpoint. They may be very well working on the same problem as you, but don’t need to hashtag it.